These Mayor Sandwiches Are Simply Meant to Be

'the nightmare before christmas' sandwiches
Image source: Disney Family | Jessica McDonald

Your picky eater wouldn’t dare argue with you about eating lunch if it was shaped like the Mayor from Halloween Town! Have a festive Halloween meal with these fun, open-faced¬†The Nightmare Before Christmas¬†Mayor Sandwiches featuring the classic two-faced character.

For more Disney magic, try this Oogie Boogie Cake:

Mayor Sandwiches


  • 2 bread slices
  • 2 tablespoons whipped cream cheese
  • 2 tablespoons red pepper hummus
  • 1 thin red bell pepper slice
  • 1 shredded cucumber strip
  • Half a can of large black olives

Helpful Tip

All cutting should be done by an adult.


  1. Cut your two slices of bread into a triangle shape, with the top of the triangle cut flat.

  2. Spread cream cheese on one slice of bread and hummus on the other.

  3. Place three olive halves stacked vertically above the brim to create the Mayor’s hats.

  4. Top each hat with two olives cut to look like the top of his hat.

  5. For the slice with hummus, use half an olive for each of his eyes, with a whole cut out of each of the middles. Use two small strips of olives to place underneath his eyes.

  6. Place your thin slice of red bell pepper in a “u” shape for his smile.

  7. For both noses, use olives to cut the shape for each side of his face.

  8. For the slice with cream cheese, use the rim of two olives for his eyes, and cut small strips of olives for his teeth, placing them in a zigzag pattern.

  9. Lastly, use a vegetable peeler to peel a piece of cucumber, cutting your strip into two thin pieces to use for his mouth.

    Image source: Jessica McDonald

Posted 3 years Ago
Subscribe to